Flag Check

17 flags to 3.

Panthers 20, Saints 17. Seven calls are disputed. Three were wrong.

See the seven calls All 21 flags

21 flags on one clock.

Every flag sits at its place on the game clock. The seven numbered marks are the calls in dispute.

Skip the chart, to the table of all 21 flags
  • 3 wrong
  • 4 questionable
  • 13 not disputed
  • 1 declined

Carolina 17 flags, 152 yards

New Orleans 3 flags, 46 yards

  1. First quarter Scoreless
  2. Second quarter Carolina leads 7 to 0
  3. Third quarter Carolina leads 10 to 7
  4. Fourth quarter Carolina wins 20 to 17
Hover or tap a mark to read the call.

Nine of Carolina’s 17 were procedural. Of those, coach Dave Canales said: “We gotta eliminate those.” Panthers Wire

All 21 flags as a table
FlagWhenOnFoulYardsStatus
1 Q1 15:00 Ryan Fitzgerald, Carolina Kickoff out of bounds Saints start at their 40. 0 Not disputed
2 Q1 13:45 Jaelan Phillips, Carolina Encroachment 5 Not disputed
3 Q1 6:26 Rasheed Walker, Carolina False start 5 Not disputed
4 Q1 3:41 Darren Waller, Carolina Offensive pass interference 10 Wrong, flag 4
5 Q1 1:43 Derrick Brown, Carolina Neutral zone infraction 5 Not disputed
6 Q2 10:52 Quincy Riley, New Orleans Defensive holding Wiped out a Saints sack. 5 Not disputed
7 Q2 10:26 Rasheed Walker, Carolina Ineligible man downfield 5 Not disputed
8 Q2 8:16 Luke Fortner, Carolina Offensive holding 10 Questionable, flag 8
9 Q2 6:43 Colby Wooden, New Orleans Defensive offside Declined. Carolina took the touchdown. 0 Declined
10 Q2 6:43 Carolina Delay of game Before the extra point. 5 Not disputed
11 Q3 15:00 Trevis Gipson, Carolina Unnecessary roughness On the kickoff return. 15 Not disputed
12 Q3 8:46 Devin Lloyd, Carolina Unnecessary roughness 15 Questionable, flag 12
13 Q3 4:00 Martin Emerson Jr., New Orleans Defensive pass interference 11 Not disputed
14 Q3 2:30 Feleipe Franks, Carolina Illegal formation On a kickoff. 5 Not disputed
15 Q3 1:31 Feleipe Franks, Carolina Unnecessary roughness 15 Wrong, flag 15
16 Q4 6:42 Trevis Gipson, Carolina Neutral zone infraction 5 Not disputed
17 Q4 6:18 Jaelan Phillips, Carolina Horse collar tackle 15 Questionable, flag 17
18 Q4 4:42 Tre’von Moehrig, Carolina Neutral zone infraction 5 Not disputed
19 Q4 4:40 Corey Thornton, Carolina Defensive pass interference Covering Chris Olave. 17 Not disputed
20 Q4 1:10 Tyrel Dodson, Carolina Face mask 15 Wrong, flag 20
21 Q4 0:28 Kool-Aid McKinstry, New Orleans Defensive pass interference 30 Questionable, flag 21

Three of the seven were wrong.

Our verdict, from written accounts by Panthers outlets. We graded no film ourselves.

  1. Flag 4: Offensive pass interference.

    Wrong Darren Waller, Carolina. First quarter, 3:41, third and 9.

    The cost
    A 13-yard catch came back. Third and 9 became third and 19, and Carolina punted.
    The case
    One account of the play called the flag “phantom,” another “admittedly weak.” We found nobody defending it.
    On the record

    “he was called for a phantom offensive pass interference to end the drive.”

    Jonathan DeLong, Cat Scratch Reader

    Rule and sources for flag 4

    Rule 8, Section 5, Article 2(g). Pass interference includes: “Initiating contact with an opponent by shoving or pushing off, thus creating separation.”

    Rule 8, Section 5, Article 3(a). Permitted contact, and the tiebreaker: “Incidental contact by an opponent’s hands, arms, or body when both players are competing for the ball, or neither player is looking for the ball. If there is any question whether contact is incidental, the ruling shall be no interference”.

    Wrong because Cat Scratch Reader calls the flag “phantom,” Panthers Wire calls it “admittedly weak,” and we found no account that defends it. Carolina Panthers On SI lists it among “some of the most egregious calls or misses that hurt the Panthers.” None says what Waller was judged to have done, and all three are Panthers outlets.

  2. Flag 8: Offensive holding.

    Questionable Luke Fortner, Carolina. Second quarter, 8:16, second and 3.

    The cost
    It erased Chuba Hubbard’s 12-yard touchdown run. Carolina needed six more snaps to score.
    The case
    WCNC’s Nick Carboni reported cameras catching coach Dave Canales asking, “Where’s the holding?!” No account says what Fortner did.
    On the record

    “disgusting holding penalty by a backup ref group to pull that touchdown from Chuba Hubbard”

    Josh Norris, on X

    Rule and sources for flag 8

    Rule 12, Section 1, Article 3(c). It is a foul if an offensive blocker: “Uses his hands or arms to materially restrict or alter the defender’s path or angle of pursuit. It is a foul regardless of whether the blocker’s hands are inside or outside the frame of the defender’s body.”

    Marked questionable. Holding is a judgment call. The objections are loud, and the Cat Scratch Reader recap wrote that the late flag “seemed questionable,” but none of them describes the block itself. Carolina did score on the drive, on fourth and goal.

  3. Flag 12: Unnecessary roughness.

    Questionable Devin Lloyd, Carolina. Third quarter, 8:46, after an 18-yard catch.

    Watch the catch

    The cost
    Fifteen more yards put the Saints at the Carolina 19. They tied the game four plays later.
    The case
    Carolina-side accounts call it a diving catch by a player not yet ruled down. The rulebook protects a player on the ground whether or not the ball is dead.
    On the record

    “Devin Lloyd was flagged 15 yards for diving on the un-downed wide receiver.”

    Jonathan DeLong, Cat Scratch Reader

    Rule and sources for flag 12

    Rule 7, Section 2, Article 1(a). The ball is dead: “when a runner is contacted by an opponent and touches the ground with any part of his body other than his hands (including the wrist) or feet (including the ankle)”.

    Rule 12, Section 2, Article 8(d). Unnecessary roughness includes: “running, diving into, or throwing the body against or on a runner whose forward progress has been stopped, who has slid or taken a knee, or who has declared himself down by going to the ground untouched and has made no attempt to advance”.

    Rule 12, Section 2, Article 8(e). And: “running, diving into, or throwing the body against or on any player on the ground either before or after the ball is dead”.

    Marked questionable. Carolina’s case is that Jordyn Tyson had not been ruled down, so somebody had to down him. Whether he was still a live runner when Lloyd reached him is the whole call. Article 8(e) covers a player on the ground whether or not the ball is dead, and Article 8(d) covers a runner who has gone down untouched and made no attempt to advance. Lloyd was checked for a concussion after the play and returned.

    On video:

  4. Flag 15: Unnecessary roughness.

    Wrong Feleipe Franks, Carolina. Third quarter, 1:31, on a punt return.

    The cost
    A return to the Saints 41 came back to the Carolina 41. Carolina went three and out.
    The case
    One account calls it a standard block. Another could not tell what the flag was for. We found nobody defending it.
    On the record

    “A standard block by Feleipe Franks was flagged, costing the Panthers 15 and a good return.”

    Zach Roberts, Carolina Panthers On SI

    Rule and sources for flag 15

    Rule 12, Section 2, Article 8(g). Unnecessary roughness includes: “unnecessarily running into, diving into, or throwing the body against or on a player who (1) is out of the play or (2) should not have reasonably anticipated such contact by an opponent, before or after the ball is dead”.

    Wrong because the only account that describes the block calls it standard, and we found none that defends the flag. Josh Norris posted on X about three minutes after it, naming no play: “and that was a phantom call.” Both written accounts are from Panthers outlets.

  5. Flag 17: Horse collar tackle.

    Questionable Jaelan Phillips, Carolina. Fourth quarter, 6:18, first and 5.

    The cost
    A 17-yard sack came off the board. The Saints got a first down instead, and scored to lead.
    The case
    By rule, a quarterback in the pocket cannot be horse-collared. Where Tyler Shough stood is the whole call.
    On the record

    “They said he was out of the pocket. I thought he wasn’t, and you’re allowed to horse collar the quarterback in the pocket.”

    Jaelan Phillips, to Panthers.com

    Rule and sources for flag 17

    Rule 12, Section 2, Article 16. The foul and its exception: “No player shall grab the inside collar of the back or the side of the shoulder pads or jersey, or grab the jersey at the name plate or above, and pull the runner toward the ground. This does not apply to a runner who is in the pocket area or in the area defined by close-line play.”

    Rule 3, Section 25. The pocket: “The pocket area is the area between the outside edges of the normal tackle positions on each side of the center extending backward to the offensive team’s end line. A player who is in possession of the ball is out of the pocket area, and the pocket area no longer exists, if any part of his body or the ball is outside of the pocket area.”

    Marked questionable. By Phillips’s account the officials said Shough had left the pocket, and nothing published settles it. The 17 yards Shough lost do not: the pocket runs back to the end line, so it is moving outside the tackles that takes a quarterback out of it. The flag turned second and 22 at the Saints 41 into first down at the Carolina 27.

  6. Flag 20: Face mask.

    Wrong Tyrel Dodson, Carolina. Fourth quarter, 1:10, after a 5-yard catch.

    The cost
    Fifteen yards moved the Saints into Carolina territory. They tied the game on a 55-yard field goal.
    The case
    The rule covers only the mask and helmet opening. The one recap of the tackle has the defender grabbing the shoulder pad, and Panthers On SI calls the flag “incorrectly called.”
    On the record

    “The Saints got a boost by a defensive face mask in which the defender grabbed the Saint’s shoulder pad.”

    Jonathan DeLong, Cat Scratch Reader

    Rule and sources for flag 20

    Rule 12, Section 2, Article 15. The foul: “If a player grasps an opponent’s facemask or helmet opening, he must immediately release it. He shall not grasp and control, twist, turn, push, or pull the facemask or helmet opening of an opponent in any direction.”

    Wrong because the one account that describes the tackle has the defender grabbing the shoulder pad, a second calls the flag “incorrectly called,” and we found none that defends it. Three other reports mention the penalty without questioning it. Both critical accounts are from Panthers outlets. The 15 yards moved the Saints from their own 42 to the Carolina 43, and they gained 6 more before the kick.

  7. Flag 21: Defensive pass interference.

    Questionable Kool-Aid McKinstry, New Orleans. Fourth quarter, 0:28, second and 10.

    Watch the play

    The cost
    Thirty yards put Carolina at the Saints 36. Ryan Fitzgerald won it from 54 as time expired.
    The case
    This one went Carolina’s way. NewOrleans.Football reported McKinstry frustrated by a “horrible, horrible” call. Four New Orleans writers put it on McKinstry instead.
    On the record

    “What is OPI”

    Cam Jordan, Saints defensive end, on X

    Rule and sources for flag 21

    Rule 8, Section 5, Article 2(a). Pass interference includes: “Contact by a player who is not playing the ball that restricts the opponent’s opportunity to make the catch”.

    Rule 8, Section 5, Article 2(g). And, for either team: “Initiating contact with an opponent by shoving or pushing off, thus creating separation.”

    Marked questionable. McKinstry and teammate Cam Jordan question it: Jordan’s post about the play implies the receiver should have been called for offensive pass interference. The MLFootball account called the flag “bogus.” But NOLA.com reported that officials determined McKinstry made contact before the ball arrived, and that he “failed to turn his head around.” Ken Trahan of Crescent City Sports wrote that he “did not get his head turned,” Who Dat Dish that he was “caught giving him the business,” and Doug Joubert of New Orleans Saints On SI that he “committed pass interference” instead of turning his head. Coach Kellen Moore said afterward: “Yeah, they called it. Yeah, obviously, again, we had plenty of calls go our way. Obviously, there’s disappointment when a call goes like that and now they’re in field range.”

    On video:

Officials were reassigned by distance.

After Friday’s ground stop, the NFL moved officials to games within driving distance of home.

A backup referee
Umpire Duane Heydt made his regular-season debut as referee. Each backup “trains throughout the year” for it, the NFL said.
No replay official on site
Replay was to run from New York, Saints Wire reported before kickoff.
What it proves
Nothing about any one call. It is the setting all 21 were made in.

How we judged them.

Wrong
Accounts of the play say the foul was not there or was weak, and we found none defending the flag.
Questionable
A judgment call with a real argument on each side.
The limits
We graded no film ourselves. Every article behind a “wrong” call is from a Panthers outlet. We found no NFL comment by game night.
Not counted

Missed calls and replay rulings are outside this page. Panthers writers also raised a missed interference against Tetairoa McMillan, an uncalled hold on Jaelan Phillips in the end zone, a ball thrown at defenders after an Alvin Kamara touchdown, and the review that left Chuba Hubbard short of the goal line. Carolina Panthers On SI and Cat Scratch Reader have those.

Two more flags drew a remark but no clear objection. The Cat Scratch Reader recap says Trevis Gipson “tapped a Saints player on the back of the helmet” on his roughness call, and that the interference call on Corey Thornton came “on an underthrown ball.” The same recap says “two personal fouls” could be argued “very incorrect” without naming them.

Every source